The 19th Edge Debate: 4th December 2003
Tipping points
'No idea is more appealing', wrote the Economist earlier in the
year in an article about the Tory leadership 'than one which appears
to offer not only an explanation for the grimness of one's predicament,
but also the possibility of escape from it'. The article was about
tipping points. The term derives from a mathematical insight known
as geometrical progression and is most commonly used to help predict
the speed at which epidemics of contagious disease are likely to
spread but also for developments such as the spectacular explosion
in mobile phone usage, or the fall in New York's crime rate in the
early 1990s. It could be a helpful lens through which to view the
success we are having with our sustainability targets.
The idea is particularly topical because of the establishment of
Margaret Beckett's recent New Sustainable Buildings Task Group.
'Clients' said Mrs Beckett, 'must demand more sustainable buildings.
Financial institutions must back developers. We need sustainability
at the heart of our skills and professional training. We need architects
and designers to incorporate .sustainability in their designs. Manufacturers
must deliver efficient buildings services and fabric components.
Builders must develop and market sustainable buildings, and we need
consumers to demand those higher .standards.'
We have been able to find few people in the industry that know
anything about this new task group or what it is likely to say when
it reports to government in February 2004, but that not withstanding,
we wondered how helpful the idea of tipping points might be in getting
the right sort of buildings build and moving towards the government's
very demanding sustainability targets more generally.
Invited speakers were:
Paper 1: No Excuse
Mark Whitby - Director of Whitbybird, champion for carbon
counting and an ICE past President.
Paper 2: Tipping Points
David Fisk - Professor of Sustainability, Imperial College
and Chief Government Scientist, ODPM
Max Fordham - Director, Max Fordham & Partners and a
CIBSE past president
The debate was chaired by Terry Wyatt, Partner, Hoare Lea and Partners
and President, CIBSE.
|